Is Singapore truly a Tax Haven?
- Thread starter BerlusconiSchmidt
- Start date
- Status
Just spoke to a Singapore based accountant regarding setting up in Singapore and their response to corp tax exemption was basically this:
- If everything is overseas then you can claim exemption from corporation tax.
- However if everything is overseas then IRAS or other regulators may question why you have a need to have a Singapore company in the first place.
- If everything is overseas then you will need to show that taxes are paid in other countries.
- Their concern is that you will end up paying a higher % elsewhere instead of the lower rates in Singapore.
I've spoken to 3-4︀ different accountants about this and get some mixed opinions still. This can't be a common︁ situation if nobody can clearly state what is and isn't possible. I'm living in Thailand︂ and revenue comes from US, Canada and UK.
- If everything is overseas then you can claim exemption from corporation tax.
- However if everything is overseas then IRAS or other regulators may question why you have a need to have a Singapore company in the first place.
- If everything is overseas then you will need to show that taxes are paid in other countries.
- Their concern is that you will end up paying a higher % elsewhere instead of the lower rates in Singapore.
I've spoken to 3-4︀ different accountants about this and get some mixed opinions still. This can't be a common︁ situation if nobody can clearly state what is and isn't possible. I'm living in Thailand︂ and revenue comes from US, Canada and UK.
I've spoken to several US accountants and their opinions are even more mixed. Some say LLC other say can't use LLC because I'm not classified as a manufacturer so S Corp is best. S Corp is 21% but can deduct salary obviously.
Finding good, reliable people in the US seems like the biggest problem, apart from their incredibly complicated tax system.
Finding good, reliable people in the US seems like the biggest problem, apart from their incredibly complicated tax system.
No, not a US person. This article explains that I essentially have effectively connected income as the transfer of ownership of my inventory to the customer occurs in the US:
https://onlinetaxman.com/foreign-owned-llc-taxation
I sell via Amazon FBA and everything is made in the far east. Apparently because of this I will need to pay federal income tax so I was told an S-Corp would be the better choice.
https://onlinetaxman.com/foreign-owned-llc-taxation
I sell via Amazon FBA and everything is made in the far east. Apparently because of this I will need to pay federal income tax so I was told an S-Corp would be the better choice.
The long discussion. I think we had this elsewhere recently. There are about an equal number of CPA and lawyers that claim you are "engaged in a US trade or business" as are against it. And most of the time the reasoning completely lacks any sense of understanding the law.
Now, the bigger question is where your company is effectively managed from. Could you please elaborate?
If you believe the ETBUS guys, note that paying taxes in the US does not exempt you from paying taxes again at the place of management. Also, even believing the ETBUS guys, you may be able to benefit from︀ a treaty, exempting you from paying tax in the US.
Long discussions, no easy solutions...︁
For Singapore, as far as I know, they are more lenient in terms of where︂ taxes are paid than Hong Kong. It seems the better choice to me.
Now, the bigger question is where your company is effectively managed from. Could you please elaborate?
If you believe the ETBUS guys, note that paying taxes in the US does not exempt you from paying taxes again at the place of management. Also, even believing the ETBUS guys, you may be able to benefit from︀ a treaty, exempting you from paying tax in the US.
Long discussions, no easy solutions...︁
For Singapore, as far as I know, they are more lenient in terms of where︂ taxes are paid than Hong Kong. It seems the better choice to me.
I live in Thailand and manage everything myself. But hoping to fly under the radar here and not get them involved so I won't benefit from any treaty.
I've mostly settled on Singapore due to the simpler system, and the people I have spoken to seem much more competent than most︀ in the US who give me little confidence. I don't know whether to push for︁ the exemption or just settle for lower (than UK) corporation tax in Singapore. I want︂ as little risk as possible so I am leaning towards just paying at this point.︃
I've mostly settled on Singapore due to the simpler system, and the people I have spoken to seem much more competent than most︀ in the US who give me little confidence. I don't know whether to push for︁ the exemption or just settle for lower (than UK) corporation tax in Singapore. I want︂ as little risk as possible so I am leaning towards just paying at this point.︃
I took the first product from the Amazon.com homepage and it's not an Amazon brand.
https://www.amazon.com/Razer-DeathAdder-Essential-Gaming-Mouse/dp/B094PS5RZQ/
I'm not involved in FBA so i don't really know how to display "sold by Amazon" but i know you can because multiple brands are doing that.
BTW how much of your income derives from:
- US?
- Canada?
- UK?
https://www.amazon.com/Razer-DeathAdder-Essential-Gaming-Mouse/dp/B094PS5RZQ/
I'm not involved in FBA so i don't really know how to display "sold by Amazon" but i know you can because multiple brands are doing that.
BTW how much of your income derives from:
- US?
- Canada?
- UK?
Just looked it up and it's as I say. Either Amazon themselves own that brand (they have their own "non-Amazon" private label brands too) or the seller is using Vendor Central which means Amazon is buying upfront like a normal retailer. When you're a vendor you relinquish control of your listings so you have no control over anything as far as I know.
There are plenty of options.
I had long discussions in regards to the taxation in the US. Is is complicated and most of the time the reasoning is wrong (or only covers half of the reality.) The facts are that all discussions about dependent agent, ownership transfer, effectively connected income, only come AFTER you are ENGAGED IN A US TRADE OR BUSINESS. The big︀ question is whether you are engaged or not. This is the question. Also, please note︁ that if you can benefit from a tax treaty, you won't have that issue in︂ the first place as your distribution center in the US won't trigger any tax consequence.︃
For the under the radar, discussion, you can follow us here
https://www.offshorecorptalk.com/th...-is-a-salary-taxed-in-hong-kong-or-not.44824/
tnt500, Roo, bananaf︄ and me all have the same issues and all of us want a solution. I︅ personally see Hong Kong as more risky than Singapore as they are more often the︆ ones asking where tax has been paid. For Singapore, you are the first one that︇ tells me this today. Maybe, we need to gather more information about all of this.︈ Guernsey would be another option.
- Amazon sells their own stuff
- Amazon Vendor Central: Amazon sells, you ship to Amazon warehouses
- Amazon Seller Central FBA: You sell, you ship to Amazon warehouses
- Amazon Seller Central Seller-Fulfilled Prime / Seller Fulfilled: You sell, you ship to the customer.
I had long discussions in regards to the taxation in the US. Is is complicated and most of the time the reasoning is wrong (or only covers half of the reality.) The facts are that all discussions about dependent agent, ownership transfer, effectively connected income, only come AFTER you are ENGAGED IN A US TRADE OR BUSINESS. The big︀ question is whether you are engaged or not. This is the question. Also, please note︁ that if you can benefit from a tax treaty, you won't have that issue in︂ the first place as your distribution center in the US won't trigger any tax consequence.︃
For the under the radar, discussion, you can follow us here
https://www.offshorecorptalk.com/th...-is-a-salary-taxed-in-hong-kong-or-not.44824/
tnt500, Roo, bananaf︄ and me all have the same issues and all of us want a solution. I︅ personally see Hong Kong as more risky than Singapore as they are more often the︆ ones asking where tax has been paid. For Singapore, you are the first one that︇ tells me this today. Maybe, we need to gather more information about all of this.︈ Guernsey would be another option.
Guys you are going off topic, the thread says "Is Singapore truly a tax have ?!!!! Open a new thread to discuss Amazon and US LLC stuff please.
Apologies.
I am planning on speaking to another accountant who seems to think profits in Singapore will indeed be exempt so I will update if anything is relevant.
Thanks - I will follow that thread. Very keen to find a solution otherwise I will need to either do nothing and continue with my UK setup or pull the trigger on Singapore and receive the startup exemptions for the first 3 years︀ to bring the rate under 17% (100% dividends, no salary).
I am planning on speaking to another accountant who seems to think profits in Singapore will indeed be exempt so I will update if anything is relevant.
Thanks - I will follow that thread. Very keen to find a solution otherwise I will need to either do nothing and continue with my UK setup or pull the trigger on Singapore and receive the startup exemptions for the first 3 years︀ to bring the rate under 17% (100% dividends, no salary).
I sent you my contact from Sovereign. If you have time, please check with him too and let me know your final analysis. I am still unsure what to do and in the very same boat as you. I am considering Guernsey, Singapore at the moment.
For the ETBUS question, I had some discussions already here:
https://www.offshorecorptalk.com/th...ould-i-pay-us-taxes-or-not.44605/#post-298727https://www.offshorecorptalk.com/threads/w8-ben-form-needed.44574/#post-298547They are both offtopic there too 🙂
For the ETBUS question, I had some discussions already here:
https://www.offshorecorptalk.com/th...ould-i-pay-us-taxes-or-not.44605/#post-298727https://www.offshorecorptalk.com/threads/w8-ben-form-needed.44574/#post-298547They are both offtopic there too 🙂
Means owner has to be resident in 0% tax place? Why it is being called loophole in Singapore rules isn't it the purpose of such law?
Some country maybe the country of your company will ask you to show residency and tax you if not a︀ resident anywhere.
What they changed in Cyprus?
Some country maybe the country of your company will ask you to show residency and tax you if not a︀ resident anywhere.
What they changed in Cyprus?
Either:
Only if the company is managed from there and fulfills︀ all requirements to be taxed.
- live in a country with 0% tax
- live in a country without PE rules
- spend less than the required days in any country to become tax resident (can be as low as 30 up to 183)
Only if the company is managed from there and fulfills︀ all requirements to be taxed.
- Status