Comparison of secure instant messengers

JohnnyDoe

Schrödinger‘s guy
Dec 29, 2008
8,247
11,255
7,730
beach
johnnydoe.com
When privacy, censorship resistance, and decentralization matter, the usual mainstream messengers won’t cut it. Instead, a number of privacy-first, often federated or decentralized instant messaging apps have emerged. Below is a comparison of the most relevant ones.

SimpleX

  • A radically different model—no user ID, no accounts. Communication is routed via intermediaries without exposing metadata.
  • No central server, completely anonymous.
  • Built around the Signal encryption protocol but avoids contact lists or phone numbers.

XMPP (with Conversations)

  • A protocol from 1999, revitalized through modern clients like Conversations on Android.
  • Federated architecture, with OMEMO encryption.
  • Mature, widely supported, and easy to self-host.

Delta Chat

  • Uses the email infrastructure (IMAP/SMTP) to send encrypted messages via OpenPGP.
  • If you have email, you already have Delta Chat—no additional servers needed.
  • Technically federated by nature of email.

Matrix (with Element)

  • A modern, federated real-time communication protocol.
  • Uses end-to-end encryption via Olm and Megolm.
  • Supports everything from simple chats to full VoIP and bridges to other networks.

Session

  • Forked from Signal, but built on a blockchain-based, decentralized network.
  • Requires no phone number or email to use.
  • Metadata-resistant and designed for anonymity.

MessengerYearArchitectureEncryptionFederation/DecentralizationSelf-HostableUnique TraitsPlatforms
SimpleX2021Decentralized (relay-based)Signal (modified)✅ Full decentralizationNo IDs, no metadata, no contact listAndroid, iOS, desktop
XMPP (Conversations)1999 / 2014Federated (XMPP protocol)OMEMO✅ FederatedMature, modular, server-agnosticAndroid, iOS, desktop
Delta Chat2017Email-basedOpenPGP✅ Via email infrastructure✅ (email)Uses existing email accountsAndroid, iOS, desktop
Matrix (Element)2014 / 2016FederatedOlm/Megolm✅ FederatedBridging to Slack/Telegram/IRC etc.Android, iOS, desktop
Session2020Decentralized (blockchain)Signal (fork)✅ Blockchain node-based⚠️ Only with stakingFully anonymous, no phone/emailAndroid, iOS, desktop
 
I would like to add :

Network protection layer: Next DNS / nym Mixnet for both financial and personal use.

Mobile protection layer: GrapheneOS only for specific devices.

Desktop protection layer: Qubes OS has some hardware support limitations.
 

JohnnyDoe.is is an uncensored discussion forum
focused on free speech,
independent thinking, and controversial ideas.
Everyone is responsible for their own words.

Quick Navigation

User Menu