Comparison of secure instant messengers

JohnnyDoe

Schrödinger‘s guy
Jan 1, 2020
9,524
1
13,805
5,133
beach
johnnydoe.com
When privacy, censorship resistance, and decentralization matter, the usual mainstream messengers won’t cut it. Instead, a number of privacy-first, often federated or decentralized instant messaging apps have emerged. Below is a comparison of the most relevant ones.

SimpleX

  • A radically different model—no user ID, no accounts. Communication is routed via intermediaries without exposing metadata.
  • No central server, completely anonymous.
  • Built around the Signal encryption protocol but avoids contact lists or phone numbers.

XMPP (with Conversations)

  • A protocol from 1999, revitalized through modern clients like Conversations on Android.
  • Federated architecture, with OMEMO encryption.
  • Mature, widely supported, and easy to self-host.

Delta Chat

  • Uses the email infrastructure (IMAP/SMTP) to send encrypted messages via OpenPGP.
  • If you have email, you already have Delta Chat—no additional servers needed.
  • Technically federated by nature of email.

Matrix (with Element)

  • A modern, federated real-time communication protocol.
  • Uses end-to-end encryption via Olm and Megolm.
  • Supports everything from simple chats to full VoIP and bridges to other networks.

Session

  • Forked from Signal, but built on a blockchain-based, decentralized network.
  • Requires no phone number or email to use.
  • Metadata-resistant and designed for anonymity.

MessengerYearArchitectureEncryptionFederation/DecentralizationSelf-HostableUnique TraitsPlatforms
SimpleX2021Decentralized (relay-based)Signal (modified)✅ Full decentralizationNo IDs, no metadata, no contact listAndroid, iOS, desktop
XMPP (Conversations)1999 / 2014Federated (XMPP protocol)OMEMO✅ FederatedMature, modular, server-agnosticAndroid, iOS, desktop
Delta Chat2017Email-basedOpenPGP✅ Via email infrastructure✅ (email)Uses existing email accountsAndroid, iOS, desktop
Matrix (Element)2014 / 2016FederatedOlm/Megolm✅ FederatedBridging to Slack/Telegram/IRC etc.Android, iOS, desktop
Session2020Decentralized (blockchain)Signal (fork)✅ Blockchain node-based⚠️ Only with stakingFully anonymous, no phone/emailAndroid, iOS, desktop
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marty McFly
I would like to add :

Network protection layer: Next DNS / nym Mixnet for both financial and personal use.

Mobile protection layer: GrapheneOS only for specific devices.

Desktop protection layer: Qubes OS has some hardware support limitations.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: GuaraniGhost

JohnnyDoe.is is an uncensored discussion forum
focused on free speech,
independent thinking, and controversial ideas.
Everyone is responsible for their own words.

Quick Navigation

User Menu