Alternative to blackcatcard

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your very detailed explanation; I must admit it is very interesting reading.‌

The way I see it, you quickly run into problems regarding the 'source of funds',‍ for example. What I mean is, if you don't pay taxes anywhere or are not⁠ registered with a residence anywhere but earn 1 million, what do you then tell the⁤ bank when they ask? And what about the banks where most require a TIN or⁣ something similar?
 
That depends on where the 1 million comes⁢ from and where you bank. But say you have a totally legitimate business, with funds︀ coming into your business bank account, then the business bank is usually fine with it.︁ And if you transfer over a dividend or distribution or something to a personal bank︂ account, you can show paperwork for that from your business if the bank asks.

And regarding personal banks, lets keep assuming the: left the UK, and split the year between︃ the UAE, Mexico and Ireland -situation. Then you can as a UAE resident open personal︄ bank accounts in the UAE, and banks there are pretty good, and it usually isnt︅ a problem to transfer over funds from a business bank account abroad to a personal︆ bank account in the UAE for a legitimate business abroad.

And in this situation you︇ can usually keep your personal UK bank accounts or open offshore UK bank accounts. And︈ with your Irish address you can also open bank accounts in Ireland and in any︉ of the numerous EMIs that support EU residents. If/when they ask you for a TIN︊ you can give them your UAE emirates id number - it is not technically a︋ TIN, the UAE doesnt have TINs, but it is generally used as one anyway. If︌ they dont accept the UAE as tax residence (Revolut doesnt for example), you can use︍ an Irish or a Mexican TIN - in many countries it is easy to get︎ a TIN even if you are not a tax resident. Or you can register in️ some developed non-bureaucratic country, like e.g. Estonia, get a TIN and then move out. And‌ then you can open bank accounts with your Estonia address and Estonia TIN.

And it's nowadays possible to live️ off crypto entirely and not even have bank accounts - quite useful if your income‌ is in crypto. There are many services where you can pay with a visa/mastercard linked‍ to crypto, or with crypto directly like Bitrefill or Travala. I know lots of people⁠ that live like this.
 
vey difficult unless you know something I don't know, what country would you be able to‍ do so?

but I can't provide a TIN (Tax identification number) because⁤ I have no tax residency in this model, what then if the bank ask ?⁣
 
It's not very difficult if you have‍ a visa/mastercard that uses crypto on the back end. Then you can live a normal⁠ life in most countries. I know quite a few people in the UAE who live⁤ like this.

However, if you dont even want a visa/mastercard/union pay card, and reject the⁣ entirety of the banking system, then it is difficult. Still I know people who live⁢ like this, in Vietnam for example. They exchange Bitcoin for cash regularly using p2p, undergound︀ OTC dealers etc, and then the economy is pretty cash based, so most things can︁ be paid with cash.

TIN is (in some cases) requested upon opening , and regularly︄ while having the account as part KYC/AML checks.
Source of Funds is a different process,︅ and doesn't really involve TIN - they want to know where your funds came from,︆ not where you are a tax resident.

Also note that in the example above the︇ UK personal accounts that you opened before leaving the UK would typically not ask for︈ TIN, as you opened them as a UK resident. Also the UAE accounts would not︉ ask for a TIN, because you opened them as a resident of the UAE and︊ that means you are de facto treated as a tax resident of the UAE by︋ UAE banks.

Most commonly banks treat residence as tax residence, because residence is way easier︌ to check, and they are from a regulatory perspective not required to check tax residency︍ (just at most collect a TIN). Checking tax residency involves checking center of vital interest︎ / permanent abode, how many days you spent in various countries, if you have a️ key to a car in Germany, a home in Spain, are registered for a doctor‌ in the Netherlands, have a child in Sweden etc. It doesn't make economic sense for‍ banks to check this.

But anyway, you can provide a TIN in this model, you⁠ have a TIN from the UK, and you can get TINs from Ireland, Mexico, and⁤ kind of from the UAE. And also I mentioned registering in Estonia, getting an Estonian⁣ TIN and then leaving Estonia. Then you could provide the valid Estonia TIN to for⁢ example Revolut and they will accept it as that meets their criteria for KYC/AML checks.︀
And then Revolut would report to Estonia and (maybe to your passport country too), and︁ then Estonia would do nothing with the information because they d see you no longer︂ live there.
Maybe sometime in the future EU firms up things around this, and Revolut︃ would get back to you saying they dont accept the Estonia TIN, but we are︄ not there yet, and this might be far into the future, and there will always︅ be ways around it.

You also have tons of people from developed countries that are︆ not perpetual travellers, just regular people, who go and live in odd countries that dont︇ issue TINs or are so corrupt that it doesnt really make a difference if they︈ issue a TIN or not.

These people are still able to keep their bank accounts︉ in the developed world, and typically just stay with the registration of their accounts in︊ the developed country of origin - no problem!

This would be the equivalent to a︋ perpetual traveller in the previous example just keeping his/her UK bank accounts even after no︌ longer being a tax resident in the UK.
 
My app doesn't work anymore, it says wrong authorization then won't grant me access, yet I‌ haven't modified anything on my phone.
 
Just an update - my blackcatcard is working.

They say..... Blackcatcard sorted a problem in‌ the international payments system with Mastercard

Just to say..... my blackcatcard is working again. Apparently‍ some issue with Mastercard been resolved. Cool.
 
My card has never stopped working to be honest, and still has the Malta IBAN.‌ The app on the phone though doesn't load at all 🙂 🙁
 
It is still a bit broken. Card is OK most of the time. But⁠ NO transfers still as they are switching IBANs....
 
Release what 6 months ago?
Anyhow I would like to see this statement backed up,‌ as I see it they had quite a few troubles and still have, but will‍ possibly go on, albeit with a different offer.
 
That's what‌ they are best to do.

they don't have a new provider ? correspondent bank ?⁠
 
They are working on "transferring IBANs to a new provider" but this is slow as‍ they do it in "batches".

Does anyone using Blackcatcard have a new IBAN?
 
How long has this process going on with them already? I would really like to‌ apply for a new account with them but without IBAN it's worthless.

Do new accounts‍ get the IBAN ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

JohnnyDoe.is is an uncensored discussion forum
focused on free speech,
independent thinking, and controversial ideas.
Everyone is responsible for their own words.

Quick Navigation

User Menu